20 questions
Scoring rubric 1–5

Manager Interview Questions to Ask Candidates

Q: How do you interview a first-time manager?

Ask about influence without authority: at time they changed a decision they did not own, mentored someone informally, or coordinated work across people. Then use situational questions for the parts they cannot have done yet — a performance conversation, a missed goal — and score the reasoning.

When you interview a manager, you are hiring for four jobs at once: managing people, delivering through a team, hiring and developing, and managing upward. Ask two behavioral questions per area, about real reports and real decisions, and score the evidence on the same scale for every candidate. A candidate who describes their management philosophy without a single named situation has told you nothing.

Try Voicit free Book a demo

4.8 out of 5 350+ reviewsUpdated: August 2026

Chosen by over 1,000 companies to document their interviews

Manager interviews drift toward philosophy: «I believe in servant leadership», «I hire people smarter than me». It sounds good, it costs nothing, and it predicts nothing.

The 20 questions below are organised around what a manager actually does all week — people, delivery, hiring, upward — and each one asks for a specific situation, tells you what a strong answer contains, and names the answer that should worry you.

20interview questions

4question sets by competency

1–5scoring rubric for every answer

Before you ask: what kind of manager does this team need?

A first-time manager of three, a manager of managers, and someone inheriting a struggling team are different hires. Decide which two areas matter most for this role and weight the scorecard accordingly. Ask every candidate the same core questions; vary only the follow-ups.

People management

Weight it more whenTeam is large, junior, or has performance problems

Signal you are looking forA hard conversation that changed something

Delivery through others

Weight it more whenDeadlines, clients, cross-team dependencies

Signal you are looking forThey can say what they stopped doing themselves

Hiring and developing

Weight it more whenTeam is growing or has high turnover

Signal you are looking forSomeone they hired or coached got promoted

Managing upward and sideways

Weight it more whenMatrix org, many stakeholders, ambiguous priorities

Signal you are looking forThey pushed back on their own manager with evidence

People management questions

Tell me about the last time you had to give someone on your team feedback they did not want to hear. What did you say, and what happened next?

What a strong answer shows: The actual words, the person’s reaction, and a change afterwards. Specific and a little uncomfortable.
Red flag: Answers in principles («I believe in candour») with no conversation they can quote.

Describe a performance problem you managed. How long did it take to act, and how did it end?

What a strong answer shows: They noticed early, set clear expectations in writing, gave real chances, and can say how it ended — including if the person left.
Red flag: Months of tolerance, or a story where the person simply «wasn’t a fit» with no process.

How do you run one-on-ones? Tell me about one that changed something.

What a strong answer shows: A cadence they keep, an agenda owned by the report, and one concrete example of a one-on-one that surfaced a problem early.
Red flag: One-on-ones are status updates, or they get cancelled when things are busy.

Tell me about someone on your team who was unhappy. How did you find out, and what did you do?

What a strong answer shows: They found out before the resignation, diagnosed the cause, and can say whether it was fixable.
Red flag: They found out from the resignation letter.

What is something a report has told you that changed how you manage?

What a strong answer shows: Specific feedback, quoted, and a visible change since.
Red flag: Nothing comes to mind. Reports have opinions; either they were not asked or not heard.

Delivery and prioritization questions

Walk me through a goal your team missed. What did you do in the weeks before it was clear you would miss it?

What a strong answer shows: They saw it coming, told their manager early, and either cut scope or moved resources. Then a change to how they plan.
Red flag: The miss is discovered at the end and explained by external factors.

When you became a manager, what did you stop doing yourself? What was hardest to let go?

What a strong answer shows: Specific work they delegated, an honest struggle, and a rule they now use.
Red flag: They still do the most important work themselves «because it is faster».

Tell me about a time your team had more work than capacity. How did you decide what dropped, and who did you tell?

What a strong answer shows: A criterion, a conversation with stakeholders, and something that was explicitly not done.
Red flag: The team worked weekends and everything got done.

Describe a decision you made that your team disagreed with. How did you handle it?

What a strong answer shows: They listened, explained the reasoning, made the call, and checked later whether the team was right.
Red flag: Either they never make unpopular decisions, or the team’s disagreement is described as resistance.

How do you know what your team is working on without micromanaging? Give me an example of catching a problem early.

What a strong answer shows: A lightweight system (a weekly review, visible work, a demo) and an example of it working.
Red flag: Daily check-ins on everything, or they find out about problems when they blow up.

Hiring and developing questions

Tell me about the best hire you have made. What did you see in the interview that others missed?

What a strong answer shows: A specific signal they looked for, and what the person went on to do.
Red flag: They «just knew», or the best hire was a referral they did not really interview.

Tell me about a hire that did not work out. What did you miss, and what do you do differently now?

What a strong answer shows: A real miss, a diagnosis of the interview process, and a concrete change.
Red flag: Every hire has worked out, or the bad hire is entirely the person’s fault.

Who is someone you developed? What did you do specifically, and where are they now?

What a strong answer shows: Concrete actions (stretch assignments, feedback, sponsorship) and an outcome — a promotion, a move, a new skill.
Red flag: «I always support my team’s growth» with no name attached.

How do you handle a high performer who wants a promotion you cannot give them yet?

What a strong answer shows: An honest conversation about the gap, a plan with a timeline, and an example of keeping (or losing) such a person.
Red flag: They promise and hope, or the person always leaves.

How do you onboard someone new to your team? What does their first month look like?

What a strong answer shows: A structured first month with a real deliverable and a check-in, and an example of an onboarding that went wrong and what changed.
Red flag: «They shadow someone» — no structure, no early win.

Managing upward and sideways questions

Tell me about a time you disagreed with your own manager’s decision. What did you do?

What a strong answer shows: They made the case once with evidence, in private, and then committed — and can describe the manager’s view fairly.
Red flag: They never disagree, or they complied and let the team see they disagreed.

Describe a time you needed something from another team that they did not want to give you.

What a strong answer shows: They understood the other team’s constraint, found a trade, and escalated only when needed and with facts.
Red flag: «I escalated» as the first and only move.

How do you deliver bad news upward? Give me an example.

What a strong answer shows: Early, with the fact first, a cause, and a plan. No burying it in a status report.
Red flag: Bad news is softened until it is not news, or delivered after the deadline.

What do you do when your manager’s priorities and your team’s reality do not match?

What a strong answer shows: They make the gap visible with data, propose options, and let the manager choose — instead of absorbing it silently.
Red flag: They protect the team by hiding the gap, or they pass the pressure straight down.

What would your current team say is your biggest weakness as a manager?

What a strong answer shows: Something credible and specific, ideally something you have already noticed in the interview, plus what they do about it.
Red flag: «I care too much», or something no report would actually say.

How to score the answers

Score each of the four areas separately on the same scale, then weight them for this role. Write the evidence — the report, the decision, the conversation — next to the number. Management interviews are where impressions do the most damage, because managers are good at interviews.

1
No example
Management philosophy only, no named situation
2
Generic example
A situation, but their own actions are vague or the outcome is missing
3
Solid example
A real report or decision, what they did, how it ended
4
Strong example
Above, plus what it cost them, what they got wrong, and a change since
5
Exceptional
Above, plus a lasting change to how the team works, and credit given to others

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What are the best interview questions for a manager position?

The ones that force a specific report, decision or conversation: the last hard feedback they gave, a performance problem and how long they took to act, a goal they missed and what they did before it was clear, a hire that failed and what they changed. Cover people, delivery, hiring and upward management, two questions each.

How do you interview a first-time manager?

Ask about influence without authority: a time they changed a decision they did not own, mentored someone informally, or coordinated work across people. Then use situational questions for the parts they cannot have done yet — a performance conversation, a missed goal — and score the reasoning.

What are red flags when interviewing a manager?

Philosophy instead of examples; performance problems tolerated for months; every hire worked out; they still do the important work themselves; bad news reaches their manager late; and the team’s disagreement is always described as resistance.

Should team members interview their future manager?

Yes, for one focused block: working style, how they run one-on-ones, how they handle disagreement. Give them two or three questions and a rubric, and treat their notes as evidence in the debrief rather than a veto.

How many questions should a manager interview include?

Eight to ten across the four areas, with follow-ups, in about an hour. The evidence you need — the words used, what it cost, what changed — usually comes from the second follow-up, so fewer questions asked properly beat a long list.

Keep reading

Interview questions to ask candidates: the complete guide Leadership interview questions Supervisor interview questions Interview scorecard template (free Excel, Word and PDF)

Stop writing up interviews by hand.

Voicit records the interview, transcribes it and fills your scorecard against the competencies you defined, so you can listen instead of typing.